The topic is locked.
Hello Friends,

Last week I did not post a topic for GD as I figured that with it being Christmas and New Year Holidays, there won't be much participation.

So here is the first GD topic for the New Year 2011:

Should journalism be kept out of the premises of censorship?

I trust the question is easy enough to understand and hope there is active participation.

As usual the winner will be awarded a cash prize of Rs. 50 and the Runner-up Rs. 25 along with 50 points each.

All participants who post at least three valid replies will be awarded 50 points in the Group Discussion. The Replies should be in a constructive manner either opposing or supporting the topic.
  • Re: Should journalism be kept out of the premises of censorship?

    by » 5 years ago


    Journalism should be kept in the premises of censorship because there are few incidents which should not be revealed. For example: If a girl gets molested and if the journalist's highlight the news with her photograph and that's the end of her life.

    http://myblogdeivigan.blogspot.com/
    http://placementandinformations.blogspot.com/

  • Re: Should journalism be kept out of the premises of censorship?

    by » 5 years ago


    These Journalist are going to worse in the last few years and they are trying to expose some unwanted issues to the public. so my point of view is that they should also be in the premises of censorship

    http://myblogdeivigan.blogspot.com/
    http://placementandinformations.blogspot.com/

  • Re: Should journalism be kept out of the premises of censorship?

    by » 5 years ago


    Let us consider the case of Common Wealth Games. These journalists bought a good news about corruption however they fail to think that they are spitting on themselves. Does anyone know what the feedback made by BBC on the news about common wealth games issue? People of India are the only one who can comment on their own works

    http://myblogdeivigan.blogspot.com/
    http://placementandinformations.blogspot.com/

  • Re: Should journalism be kept out of the premises of censorship?

    by » 5 years ago


    In a democratic country, freedom of expression is of paramount importance. A journalist cannot do justice to his job if he is unduly obstructed from writing his views freely and without fear. A journalist ought to be free, fair, frank, fearless. Censor will cripple journalism.

    The only restriction on journalist can be with regard to matter of national security. To ensure security of nation, censorship is not necessary. The judicial system is there to check it. If any individual is offended, he may move court for damages for contempt. The leakage of secure govt or defence information will lead to action under official Secret Act and the officers leaking information will be considered more guilty than the journalist. similarly, an aggrieved person may bring suit for damages in respect of any defamation. Hence, censor is not required.

    It will suffice that a code of conduct for journalists is made applicable. The journalist will take this code of conduct in consideration. Any action by Journalist Guild or body will be taken if specific case is brought to notice.

    G. K. Ajmani Tax consultant
    http://gkajmani-mystraythoughts.blogspot.com/


  • Re: Should journalism be kept out of the premises of censorship?

    by » 5 years ago


    Very interesting topic and is quiet suitable in present scenorio.
    "Should journalism be kept out of the premises of censorship?"

    Well i first want to say NO and then YeS..which means that neutrality is to be maintained depending on the sensitivity of the news they are publishing or broadcasting..

    I agree with Deivigan that Journalist are making fun of themselves by concentrating on unncessary things inorder to bring some scams,corruptions etc..Though these are illegal things and need solutions the way they present the facts helps other culprits to escape easily.

    There are many such examples where crimes are committed too base on the information provided by media and jounalist.So depending on situation and sensitivity of a journalist or media should need decide cencorship... :)

  • Re: Should journalism be kept out of the premises of censorship?

    by » 5 years ago


    I also agree with @ Gulshan
    "In a democratic country, freedom of expression is of paramount importance. A journalist cannot do justice to his job if he is unduly obstructed from writing his views freely and without fear. A journalist ought to be free, fair, frank, fearless. Censor will cripple journalism"

    and due to the right of expression involved in the profession they should act accordingly and wisely instead of bring exposing confidential information which can only damage the society.

    If we consider the Mumbai blast, media is the main cause for killing innocent people due to their uncensored clips shown on TV..which allowed the terrorist to know upto date information on the moves taken by security persons..It is very pity that at that time no one even thought that how dangerous it is..The media and journalist just expressed their freedom of expression.. :S :(

  • Re: Should journalism be kept out of the premises of censorship?

    by » 5 years ago


    In order to add few points to Rajani after the rescue operation there was a big issue regarding their dress that they were not bullet proof and a bullet went past their suit and these journalists took advantage of this issue.

    I know how important the issue is however at the same time you are giving some tips to our enemies regarding our defense issues and it should have not been telecast and there is a rule that any military issues should not be telecast and it should be dealt under the wraps.

    Come on guys just think whether are we able to hear any military issues regarding America, Russia or even china. Only in India we hear all issues which should not be dealt in public.

    http://myblogdeivigan.blogspot.com/
    http://placementandinformations.blogspot.com/

  • Re: Should journalism be kept out of the premises of censorship?

    by » 5 years ago


    A key Wikileaks document which should have resulted in stories calling into question the tactics used by USA against many countries itself makes journalism be not kept out of the premises of censorship as what we get is real picture by journalism

    internet regulation should be kept to a minimum,“but the premise is simple: In addition to infringing human rights, ... “We should not labor under the illusion that censorship is some sort of competitive advantage as is proven by wikileaks

    THANKS! THIS REALLY HELPED A LOT! Share with World now

    http://share-ask.com/category/peoples-articles-news-now/

  • Re: Should journalism be kept out of the premises of censorship?

    by » 5 years ago


    Even as some journalists risk their lives to uncover corruption and other stories to serve the public, others in their profession like wikileak ,jouranlist swooping in lives of filmstars is darkside should such coverage for trp is unjustifiable

    it's true there was some great journalism committed. But there were costs: When the business model started to implode in competition for profit as aim & we see darkside of journalist

    THANKS! THIS REALLY HELPED A LOT! Share with World now

    http://share-ask.com/category/peoples-articles-news-now/

  • Re: Should journalism be kept out of the premises of censorship?

    by » 5 years ago


    It has been rightly stated in some posts in the thread that many journalists are acting irresponsibly. There are black sheep in any profession. It is for the profession to evolve an internal mechanism and curb any unhealthy practice. There should be clear cut professional ethics guidelines. I feel that many journalist follow ethical practice. It has been state in a post that if a journalist publishes a news item of molestation with girl's photo and identity, she will be put to harm. I agree with this apprehension. However, i have noticed that the local dailies at Agra exercise utmost care and they give fake names of affected individuals and state that the name is changed to hide actual identity.

    G. K. Ajmani Tax consultant
    http://gkajmani-mystraythoughts.blogspot.com/


You do not have permissions to reply to this topic.
Powered by CjForum