Yesterday a lone Muslim gunman shot dead 4 marines at 2 naval establishment in USA. Such cases are galore and one can recollect the massacre at Fort Hood when a Muslim major gunned down 21 servicemen. We are not imune in India and in 1965 war an order to disperse fighters at Kalaikunda was ignored and 8 fighters were destroyed on ground. A similar danger was averted in 1971 war when jet bombers were NOT comauflaged and left as sitting ducks to PAF in Agra. One can also recollect the famous Indian spy mission of 1959 when info was leaked to Pak and the canberra was shot down. The government now has a concientious decision to have no minority in RAW. Is it correct.?

Like it on Facebook, Tweet it or share this topic on other bookmarking websites.

all sorts of terrorists are dangerous. This has notrhing to with particular religion. 


G. K. Ajmani Tax consultant
http://gkajmani-mystraythoughts.blogspot.com/

Terrorist have no religion. Their only religion is to kill other human beings on earth. But agree that most of the terrorists are from one community or religion and their target is destroy all other religion on earth.


http://www.comparenshop.in

Minority alone should not blamed for leaking of information to enemy countries or tp Pak

4 armed forces personnel nabbed for spying for Pakistan

http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/4-armed-forces-personnel-nabbed-for-spying-for-pakistan/article6719368.ece

 

These back stabbers are present in every community, not only in minorities but can from majorities. 


http://www.comparenshop.in

Devils and saints are present in every religion and community. It is not proper to blame a particular religion to leak information to enemy countries. Many Muslim Jawans laid their lives and won coveted awards of Parm Vir chakra durin Kargil war.

Col.Hanifuddin was killed in the battle field. His mother gave a statement that I feel quite proud that my son laid down his life for the cause of the country and I wish I could give other sons also for this noble cause. Subsequently many more Muslim soldiers and officers died and their parents also made similar statements.

http://ecumene.org/IIS/csss18.htm

 

 

One of the main point I have raised is that the SPG and RAW have no minority for last 3 decades. Any comment on it?

In the third year of UPA-2, the then prime minister Manmohan Singh called a meeting of top officials of the Special Protection Group (SPG), the Research and Analysis Wing (RAW) and the Intelligence Bureau (IB) to seek advice on whether the representation of Muslims in the intelligence agencies could be increased, whether they should be allowed to join RAW and whether to end the ban on the entry of Sikhs and Muslims into SPG. The officers reportedly pointed out that any such move would be risky. They asked who would take the blame if something went wrong after the established system was tinkered with. Nothing came out of that meeting and the issue was never raised again.

This itself is my comment.

 

http://www.tehelka.com/the-bias-against-minorities-in-intelligence-recruitments/

 

A Hindu RAW officer is reported to have defected to USA after selling secrets. So should Hindus be  banned from joining RAW and SPG. Some persons will go to any length to satisfy their minority phobia. Are'nt there better topics for discussion

Thank you said by: Gulshan Kumar Ajmani

Well said. and you raised an apt question.

 

Thank you said by: vijay
vijay wrote:

A Hindu RAW officer is reported to have defected to USA after selling secrets. So should Hindus be  banned from joining RAW and SPG. Some persons will go to any length to satisfy their minority phobia. Are'nt there better topics for discussion

 

We  are discussing an important issue and not something frivolous. One man defecting is not the issue , it concerns policy. I am asking is this policy correct  of not having minorities in RAW and SPG. Remember teh army is also 99% Hindu/ Sikh and no Muslim regiment though many times a proposal was put. We cant run away. I have served with Muslims under my command as Commanding officer and they are fine people. Try to raise the discussion to  a higher level. in any case I have just raised a discussion point and will not participate further. 

 

You do not have permissions to reply to this topic.