How could a century old lullaby that every Malayali treasures be translated to Tamil and send for Oscar Nominations? :evil: :evil:
The original was written by Irayimman Thampi a century back for Swathi Thirunal of Travancore. Not only his mother but every mother used to make her kid sleep listening to this lovely song. Even after years, it has not lost its glory and still it's the best lullaby in Malayalam literature.
http://www.firstpost.com/bollywood/did-bombay-jayashree-copy-the-legendary-malayalam-lullaby-586495.html
click this link to hear the song.....really amazing
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kPOLSSOfUGY

Just check the wikipedia to get its English translation :evil: :evil:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omanathinkal_Kidavo
Irayimman Thampi trust has already filed a case against Bombay Jayshree for stealing the song

Meera sandhu
Like it on Facebook, Tweet it or share this topic on other bookmarking websites.
no response :unsure: :unsure:

Today I read in newspapers.....the idea of taking that popular song was decided 2 years back. They have got prrofs. A Tamil poem was also used in the movie, but given credits...not to this Malayalam lullaby. She wrote the lyrics, gave tunes and sang too. Then she send it for oscar nominations and was accepted :angry:

Meera sandhu
How could a century old lullaby that every Malayali treasures be translated to Tamil and send for Oscar Nominations? :evil: :evil:
The original was written by Irayimman Thampi a century back for Swathi Thirunal of Travancore. Not only his mother but every mother used to make her kid sleep listening to this lovely song. Even after years, it has not lost its glory and still it's the best lullaby in Malayalam literature.
http://www.firstpost.com/bollywood/did-bombay-jayashree-copy-the-legendary-malayalam-lullaby-586495.html
click this link to hear the song.....really amazing
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kPOLSSOfUGY

Just check the wikipedia to get its English translation :evil: :evil:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omanathinkal_Kidavo
Irayimman Thampi trust has already filed a case against Bombay Jayshree for stealing the song

This matter is under investigation. Its to be noted that Lullabies are public properties and there is no copyright for them. Our famous lullabies written by Annamacharya were rewritten by several authors in cinema field. At that time the copyright authorities decided that those old lullabies don't have any copyright restrictions.
[quote="rambabu" post=320820
This matter is under investigation. Its to be noted that Lullabies are public properties and there is no copyright for them. Our famous lullabies written by Annamacharya were rewritten by several authors in cinema field. At that time the copyright authorities decided that those old lullabies don't have any copyright restrictions.[/quote]

But she should have told the truth instead of hiding it :)

Meera sandhu
[quote="rambabu" post=320820
This matter is under investigation. Its to be noted that Lullabies are public properties and there is no copyright for them. Our famous lullabies written by Annamacharya were rewritten by several authors in cinema field. At that time the copyright authorities decided that those old lullabies don't have any copyright restrictions.


But she should have told the truth instead of hiding it :)[/quote]

As I told you that developing a lullaby based on an ancient source was never taken as an offense. Perhaps Jayshree must have thought its not necessary to tell that the original was from Swathi thirunal.
[quote="rambabu" post=320820
This matter is under investigation. Its to be noted that Lullabies are public properties and there is no copyright for them. Our famous lullabies written by Annamacharya were rewritten by several authors in cinema field. At that time the copyright authorities decided that those old lullabies don't have any copyright restrictions.


But she should have told the truth instead of hiding it :)


As I told you that developing a lullaby based on an ancient source was never taken as an offense. Perhaps Jayshree must have thought its not necessary to tell that the original was from Swathi thirunal.[/quote]

If so, why did she give credits to a Tamil classic for the same movie? :S

Meera sandhu
no response :unsure: :unsure:

Today I read in newspapers.....the idea of taking that popular song was decided 2 years back. They have got prrofs. A Tamil poem was also used in the movie, but given credits...not to this Malayalam lullaby. She wrote the lyrics, gave tunes and sang too. Then she send it for oscar nominations and was accepted :angry:


Translation can never be termed as lifting. At the most Jayshree may be charged for not acknowledging.
Could you please anyone let me know the date when the results (Oscar 2013) are going to be announced? I am eagerly looking forward to answers.

Born to express, not to impress.
http://royalrobsideas.blogspot.in/
You do not have permissions to reply to this topic.